I recently decided to get back into the world of electric guitars. Some 15 years ago, I had mostly moved into the world of acoustic guitars, as I lived in a small home and I appreciated not having such a clutter of wires and such.
I start this entry with a growing sense that I am becoming an old man trying to use complex new devices and software. But my own growing difficulties as a user case study are paired, as they often are, by the challenges of a new hardware and technology company trying to create a compelling value equation. Some companies still thrive by making rugged, reliably loud and evocatively rich-sounding amplifiers for electric guitars. But, the mere existence of digital processors which might obviate the need for effect pedal chains, wifi, Bluetooth, and smartphones creates a temptation for manufacturers of some amps to "go smart" in order to deliver greater value at a budget-friendly price. The realm created by these new technologies has its benefits, but comes with a lot of baggage.
I will start with a bullet list of issues I feel are presented by my new Spark 2 amplifier.
Smartphone App
The Spark app, which I used from an Android Pixel 9, is nice, but has issues. I will riff through them in no special order.
Upon first launching the app, it asks if you'd like to connect to a Spark Amp. Provided you've previous established these associations to a particular amp, this question is utterly idiotic. Connect immediately the most recent (likely, the only) amp to which the phone has been paired. File this under "DUH". If other options were needed in the moment (e.g., to pair to another, newly-acquired amp), these should be accessed by interrupting an immediate process of connecting to the previous amp.
Given that the product family now incorporates - indeed, almost demands - use of a smartphone app, the gates of Hell are open. By which, I mean, every buzzword is represented and accessible through the app, to varied result. There is "AI" in the form of "players" who will listen to a bit of what you play and then offer some backing tracks, such as a bassline. This is interesting, but is accessed through an interface that is already glutted with more essential fare. It should be factored out into another app, perhaps.
Vitally, the smartphone app should allow at least an option to extend the device's timeouts for sleep mode or lockscreen activation while active and connected to an amp. I keep these timeouts rather short on my phone for the sake of security, but it is a total buzzkill to have to keep waking up your phone (or even entering a passcode or biometric signal) simply to keep working with your guitar amp.
"Tones"
Users of old school amps are used to creating the "sound" of their instrument using knobs (volume, gain, boosts or cuts to various frequency bands) on the amplifier. Other modifications to the sound are generally obtained by knobs on foot pedals, each of which typically offers a specific family of functions. The routing of the signal is expressed by the external cords that connect these pedals to each other, the instrument and the amplifier.
A smart, "soft" amp such as the Spark 2 doesn't preclude the use of such pedals, but offers the promise that much of their function can be digitally modelled within the amp's chassis through digital signal processing and high performance chips that can apply these tweaks in real time. The digital "pedals" in the Spark 2 app look like familiar metal foot pedals, and populate a fixed-order "signal chain" in the app, which you can access via an Android or IOS device.
In addition to these rich apps, the amp itself features physical knobs. Each has a familiar index mark on its circumference, which can be swept across the customary 0-10 range (11 is reserved for future updates, I suppose). However, the position of these knobs does not necessarily reflect those in force in the modelled sound the amp is delivered! If you use the app to apply a new preset "tone", or to alter the loaded one the amp is actually delivering, the knob positions become a possible lie: the Treble knob may be set at 5 while the amp is delivering a Treble setting of 7. The fix? Stop using dots on the knobs and make the fixed circumferential scale against which they register be a circular bar chart showing the present value in effect. If you rotate the knob, the LED lights will show where "the dot" is. If this parameter is altered by any action taken through the app, the same indication can be represented at the knob.
On the Spark 2, there is a "preset selector" knob with 4 positions and 2 banks (8 presets in all). The bank of preset being used is depicted by either red or green LED indicators alongside digits 1-4 of the preset within the bank being used. These settings are, however, conveyed in the app as preset slots 1A, 2A, 3A, 4A, 1B, 2B, 3B, 4B. This is confusing in two ways. It doesn't tell you that "A" is red, and "B" is green. Furthermore, it emphasizes the least significant variable (preset number) rather than the most significant variable (the bank). The fix? Reverse the order and rename the banks. Presets would then be named "Red 1", "Red 2"... "Green 4".
External GUI Interface via separate device
You can't really control the Spark 2 without use of the app. At best, the device itself, is intended to offer quick access to 8 tones stored (in red and green banks of four) that you have defined by use of a device running the app.
This makes sense, to a point. It allows the manufacturer to rely on the fact that 99% of its customers have a smartphone capable of running their app. They can factor out the cost of making this smartphone device. But, it comes with a cost. There is the tension between app and knob position as cited above, and the oddity that the user has one more "thing" he/she has to attend to/juggle - the smartphone or tablet.
A suggestion would be to bake into the device an Android-based interface to replace all of the knobs (excepting those whose settings are not reflected in the digital presets, i.e., "Music" and "Guitar"). This would intrinsically connect to the local amp on power-up and have its touchscreen affixed to the top of the amp. It would add to the cost, but manageably so - how much does an Android phone of 5 year old vintage, sans circuits for cellular, GPS, bluetooth and other particulars, cost?
Spark Link
I bought the Positive Grid wireless plug dongle pair called Spark Link. It's ok, I think, but it needs work. First off, the transmitter (which you plug into your instrument) and the receiver (which you plug into your amp) are almost indistinguishable. The transmitter has a black plastic collar around its 1/4-in plug, and the receiver has a gold metal one. It would be better to augment this with embossed letters or symbols, perhaps T and R, or a Victrola and a Terrier.
The two devices share the quirk that their power switch must be given an overly long "long press" to toggle them on and off. If nothing else is changed, this long press minimum duration should be decreased - with the Spark 2 amp, you literally have at least 6 seconds "work" just to get things powered up.
Additionally, when the transmitter is plugged into many guitars (as on a Telecaster), the LED indicating it has turned on is not going to be readily visible. Can it be made so that the act of inserting the 1/4-in plug into the guitar turns it on? Or, perhaps better, can the power switch be made a simple slider?
Also, specifically for the receiver... can this be optionally be built into the amp, or can a small cubby hole allow the existing dongle to be inserted and the door shut? Such a configuration could perhaps allow the device to receive power from the amp's battery or AC plug, could turn it on whenever the amp is powered on, and could override the amp's 1/4-in input plug when the latter is empty.
To summarize the above, I think an idea embodiment would allow the user to have a Spark amp that has an integrated receiver for a Spark Link transmitter. The receiver will always have power when the amp is on, and the transmitter will have a slider switch to turn it on/off. The user will have only one dongle to charge and keep track of.
Optional Battery for the Spark 2
This $79 option is ideally implemented. The amp has a little cubby hole for it, with a door to snap shut once it is installed. The battery has a fairly good endurance, as far as I can tell, and charges whenever the amp is plugged in. Morever, the amp remains usable when the battery is receiving this charge (unlike my Traynor busking amp, which is either charging or playing).
If you wish to have one fewer thing to tote about when going to play somewhere, get this battery. It has my unreserved endorsement.